There is NO way that someone can say "Yes this works" or "No it doesn't", because you are not all those people. I've used plenty of products that other people have used and hated while I loved them, and vice versa.

Try it out, see if it works for you. Because the only way you will know is through trial and error, even if you use something that is designed for your skin type.

neutrogena test on animals, so it shouldnt matter whether it works or not, they have on some of there bottle that they are against animal testing which is hypocritical because all their products are tested on animals.

Take SkinID
It's not worth it to use Proactiv when it's gonna take even longer to get rid of your acne. I've heard very bad reviews for proactive and good for SkinID

I have been wondering the same thing, although Neutrogena is my favorite line of face products.

But I have been using a cleanser called ZapZyt and it contains almost all-natural products and no alcohol and it has done a very good job compared to other higher priced items.
Try it, it won't hurt to waste 5 dollars compared to 20, and I promise it gives results.

I tried Skid id for one year. It does work well. I had to change my regimen twice, when I was in school, I needed stronger creams and when on vacation it changed again. I had to stop using it since it got too expensive. Good product though.

Do a Google "skinID. Skin Deep Database" & learn how in tests by an independent product tester Skin Deep Database some ingredients in this product were rated as being highly skin & health harming. Skin Deep Database provides information and safety of use of many thousands of personal care, cosmetic and skin medicating products. The ratings given indicate the level of concern posed by exposure to the ingredients in the product. You will see some ingredients(particularly fragrance) were rated as being highly hazardous to skin (and health) You can find on the Database other brands that were tested and rated as being non harming and safe to use.

Okay I used this product about a year and half ago for about three months (which was way way too long.) I do not remember the names or numbers of my products but I do remember that bottles were blue, green and orange. It was around $30-$35 at least when I purchased it. At the time I had cystic acne (which thankfully I no longer have) and this did nothing to control it and only made it worse. I will never purchase the Neutrogena Skin ID or anything thing else from them for that matter beacuse everything that I have made me breakout badly!

I have suffered with acne since Middle School and I am now almost 30 years old. I have used several over the counter acne products, Proactiv and I have also seen a dermatologist for several years. However, I was never completely satisfied with the results. So I decided to try Skin ID, I have been using this acne treatment for almost a month.

I am being completely truthful, I noticed a difference by the next morning! My acne has cleared up about 90%. It has helped with my acne, small bumps, black heads, white heads, and it has also smoothen my skin. I only use Skin ID once a day to reduce my skin from drying. As a result, I am completey satisfied with this product and I would definitely recommed anyone who suffers with acne to use Skin ID.

I got skin Id about a month ago and it worked great for the 1st week! People would notice how clear and soft my face got, and i even started to use less make up. I thought it was the best thing ever! Then after a couple of weeks my faces started to dry up and peel. I thought it was part of the treatment and get new skin or something. ha i was stupid. All my acne came back and even more showed up. I'm very upset. I feel as if I got scammed. It cost so much too... I also got a free gift and got body wash with s.a. I had mild back acne. This body wash just made it worse. What is this?! I'll just try proactive.